Disclaimer: We sustain our work & review products through paid collaborations.
The Big Dilemma of Medical Alert Warranty

The Big Dilemma of Medical Alert Warranty


“Anything that can go wrong, will go wrong” says Murphy’s Law, which is especially true when it comes to medical alert equipment. Seniors might absentmindedly spill a cup of coffee on the help button or the base station could fall out of their hands while trying to relocate it. Or it could be other issues that arise, such as thieves snatching an expensive mobile button along with a purse. A faulty, damaged, or lost medical alert system presents a hole in the senior’s safety net that needs to be immediately fixed, and that’s what the warranty is for, right? Well, not really, since claiming a refund is a tricky mistress, with companies being strict on what kind of damage can warrant a free replacement.

The big dilemma of medical alert warranty

Limited or standard warranty

In cases where a medical alert company advertises a warranty for its products, it typically lasts for one or two years from the date of purchase and provides protection against a limited number of circumstances. For example, if the device arrives to your doorstep damaged or it doesn’t work properly after installation, then the company will send a free replacement. Whether or not you will need to pay for the shipping of this depends on the provider in question, but in most situations you should expect an uphill battle to prove that it wasn’t you who caused the damage.

The most frequent reason that someone might need the warranty is to request a battery replacement. The help buttons, pendants and the portable base stations come with a built-in battery that can be only replaced by the company. Don’t tinker with the unit yourself because this will violate any warranty; contact the operators via phone instead and ask for this to be resolved. This process will again involve sending the equipment back and waiting for a new one to arrive, although most companies pay the shipping fee in these cases. Unfortunately, factory flaws and battery swaps are the only major faults that are covered by a standard warranty.

Premium protection

If the limited warranty doesn’t cover damaged or stolen objects, then what can be done to avoid paying a hefty fee for the replacement? Don’t worry, since medical alert companies will have you covered with a small insurance fee, usually called something like ‘premium’ or ‘premiere’ protection. This is basically either a small subscription or a one-time charge to receive an extended warranty, but the term ‘premium protection’ certainly has a better ring to it. By deciding to pay for this you’ll become eligible for one cost-free replacement, now covering a wider range damages and even theft.

Premium warranties come in many flavors depending on the company selling them. Medical Guardian and Bay Alarm Medical charge an extra $5 per month, though the latter will also send through a surge protector as a gift too. Other providers might ask for a one-time payment or include a full warranty as part of a higher-tier subscription plan. Mind you, paid warranties won’t guarantee an infinite number of replacements and after the first one you will need to arrange another option, otherwise you’ll be fined if the device breaks again.

Free equipment on Medical Guardian's MGMini for limited time
Medical Guardian logo
Get the MGMini device at zero cost, free activation, free shipping, and a free lockbox by visiting Medical Guardian's website through our affiliate link. This offer is only available until May 13th.
Get MGMini for Free

Do I really need expensive coverage?

This is a tricky question. Accidents can happen when you least expect them, and the purpose of a warranty is to safeguard the owner from paying a hefty fee. On one hand, $5 per month is far less severe than paying $350 as compensation, but if nothing does happen to the device then the extra fee might feel like a waste of money. To give a more useful answer, consider the person the medical alert system is intended for and the type of equipment they will be using. If you buy the system for a senior who is accident-prone, then it goes without saying that premium protection is necessary.

Alert1 mobile button

Elderly patients suffering from dementia are likely to forget where they placed the help button, in which case it might be safer to order multiple pendants or wristbands. However, should the aging relative still be in top shape physically and mentally and wants to avoid spending too much, then it’s worth the risk of not added extra protection. Just make sure to highlight the costs involved, and therefore the importance of taking care of the medical alert unit.


Best medical alert systems of 2025

Editors' choice

Medical Guardian

Editor's rating:
Quick response in emergencies
Accurate fall detection functionality
Protection anywhere you go
Clear, flexible plan options
Value

MobileHelp

Editor's rating:
Reliable help on-the-go
Works anywhere with signal
Extra safety and convenience
GPS tracking
Spanish

LifeFone

Editor's rating:
Coverage wherever you are
Great upfront savings
No hidden start-up costs
Predictable, flexible pricing
Mobile system

Medical Alert

Editor's rating:
Locates user in emergencies
Help beyond urgent needs
Sends alerts automatically
Accessible for diverse users
Professional installation

Lifeline

Editor's rating:
In-home and mobile devices
Smartphone app
No long-term contracts
+40 years of experience
Equipment variety

Alert1

Editor's rating:
Fits different lifestyle needs
Lower upfront cost
Risk-free
Customize for extra safety
Couples

One Call Alert

Editor's rating:
Support when you need it
Works anywhere with coverage
Fast, accurate emergency help
No extra maintenance costs

Discussions

Share your thoughts, ask questions, and connect with other users. Your feedback helps our community make better decisions.

©2012-2025 Best Reviews, a clovio brand – All rights reserved