Disclaimer: We sustain our work & review products through paid collaborations.
How a Simple Coding Error Became a Massive Data Breach

How a Simple Coding Error Became a Massive Data Breach


In late February 2017, Cloudflare Inc., one of the world’s largest internet security companies, was busted for leaking personal and sensitive data all over the internet for months without anyone realizing it. This is a rather ironic turn of events, since the company involved is an internet service aimed directly at increasing the security of websites, offering DNS services, preventing the always feared DDoS attacks and even configuring SSL encryptions for other companies, such as UberOkCupidCisco and FitBit. In short, Cloudflare is one of the world’s main companies contributing to a safer internet. Or at least it was, just until now.

In fact, this vulnerability was so vast and serious that it got its own nickname, Cloudbleed, striking fear in millions of users. Although the company still wasn’t able to specify an accurate number, we know that at least 150 of Cloudflare’s websites or services, and nearly 3,500 domains suffered from the aforementioned data leaks. And all it took to happen was just a simple coding error.

More smoke than fire?

The internet community needed anything but another serious data breach, especially after the infamous Yahoo scandal where something as 1 billion accounts were compromised. More shockingly, the problem could’ve been discovered way earlier: the entire Cloudbleed event dates back to September 2016, which means that data was leaking for about 6 months without anyone having a clue about it. And if it wasn’t for a Google security researcher in February 2017, the data breach could still be happening for God knows how much time. The compromised data included encryption keys, chat logs, cookies, IP addresses, member IDs, passwords and a whole lot more.

However, what makes Cloudbleed more impressive is that it was caused by the simplest of errors: a coding bug in one of the many HTML tags composing any internet page. To tell a long story short, the “>=” tag was accidentally replaced by a “==”, and the Cloudflare apocalypse began. Pages having these wrong tags caused Cloudflare’s proxy servers to reveal data belonging to previous users in the webpage source or at the bottom of a page on the next user’s browser.

Password Discovered
Up to 73% off NordVPN 2-year plans
NordVPN logo
Subscribe to NordVPN through our affiliate link and save up to 73% on 2-year plans. Do it with no fear by knowing that your purchase is protected by a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Save Up to 73% on NordVPN

Thankfully, once the issue was found and communicated to the company by Google Project Zero’s researcher, Cloudflare took immediate action and not just stopped the leak, but it also released a security patch to the entire system within only 7 hours. However, despite Cloudbleed’s apparent severity, a former Cloudflare employee stated that chances of having major impact on regular users is pretty low. Furthermore, the company is confident that no hackers were able to find the leak before Google did, since there was no detectable increase of requests in any of the websites run by Cloudflare during Cloudbleed. In fact, curiously the logs on Cloudflare systems show that the leak’s peak took place between the 13th and 18th of February, during which only one in every 3,300,000 HTTP requests was leaking the data.

Is Cloudflare still safe?

Although there was more than enough time for wrongdoers to compromise the leaked information, Cloudflare reacted quickly and successfully averted a massive jump scare – unless some hackers secretly discovered the leak (which is very unlikely). Still, the company strongly suggests users not only to change their passwords, but to opt for two-factor authentication as well to be defended against hackers more effectively.


Best VPN services of 2025

Editor's choice

NordVPN

Editor's rating:
Easy to use on any device
Extra privacy and file sharing
Comprehensive online protection
Fast and reliable connections
Security

Surfshark

Editor's rating:
Easy to use everywhere
Enhanced online privacy
Fast and secure connections
Protect unlimited devices
Multi-device users

IPVanish

Editor's rating:
Protect all your devices
Ensures user privacy
Help anytime you need it
Strong online protection
Gaming

ExpressVPN

Editor's rating:
Works on all major platforms
Fast, smooth browsing
Easy for anyone to use
Added features for flexibility
Traveling

CyberGhost VPN

Editor's rating:
Enhanced privacy and security
Fair prices
Flexible IP address options
Protects all your devices
Streaming

ZoogVPN

Editor's rating:
Affordable VPN solution
Fast and stable connections
Straightforward platform
Protects your online privacy
Torrenting

Private Internet Access

Editor's rating:
Multiple device compatibility
Keeps your IP address private
Suitable for all users
Tailor settings to your needs
Beginners

TunnelBear

Editor's rating:
Intuitive and easy to use
Extra privacy and security
Blocks trackers and ads
Smooth, fast browsing

Discussions

Share your thoughts, ask questions, and connect with other users. Your feedback helps our community make better decisions.

©2012-2025 Best Reviews, a clovio brand – All rights reserved