Best Reviews logo
Best Reviews may receive compensation for its content through paid collaborations. See how we sustain our work & review products.
Delete or Overwrite: Does It Make Any Difference?

Delete or Overwrite: Does It Make Any Difference?

By István F.István F. Verified by Adam B.Adam B. Last updated: July 18, 2024 (0)

When you think of the way that file removal is graphically presented, it’s easy to see how everyday users are convinced that the data is gone forever. However, digital trash much like real trash leaves traces behind and even if you take the trash out ready for the garbage collector, it’s still available for anyone to peek in on and snatch details of you from there. But they will need to act fast, otherwise the trash is taken care of and ultimately becomes mission impossible to recover any of the data thrown away.

What happens when I remove a file?

Imagine a huge library of books and reference materials: that’s your storage disk. As you save more and more data onto the disk, it’s like bringing more and more books into the library, filling it up. An index of the books sitting on the shelves is needed so that as the books flow in the catalog grows as well, indicating which book you will find on which shelf. In this metaphor, a book represents a ‘cluster’ for a storage disk.

Delete or overwrite: does it make any difference?

When you delete a file you’re essentially marking that part of the shelf as free and updating the index to say that this book is no longer in your library. However, it doesn’t mean that the book has been taken off the shelf, so if someone happens to be around shortly after this update, the librarian (AKA the file system in this case) will still remember the old catalog and its content. This is what data recovery applications do when running a quick scan. But as time goes by the old books placed on these shelves marked as free are replaced by new books, reusing that original space – exactly as it happens on a storage disk too.

When data is deleted, it remains on the storage disk but is hidden from the user and the space it occupies is marked as free. Then, when the file system needs that space, it will put new data into that cluster, removing the existing data and lowering the likelihood of data recovery.

What happens when the file system overwrites data?

Sticking to the library metaphor, overwriting is the equivalent of taking the book marked as no longer needed off the shelf and ripping its pages out, making it useless. But if a knowledgeable person who has an idea of the page order collects the pieces, the book can still be glued back together. That’s what data recovery apps do.

Operating systems and third-party apps offer the option to “secure delete” a file, which essentially means it will be put through a shredder, signaling the ultimate end of the data. Privacy-conscious people will choose to securely erase data from a computer in order to remove any trace of its existence. When choosing this option, the file system essentially runs an algorithm that overwrites the selected cluster several times, making it certain that data recovery is impossible. Overwriting replaces old data with new, but it doesn’t completely prevent data recovery. Deleting securely or overwriting a cluster multiple times erases every trace of the previously stored data.


Best data recovery software of 2024

Editor's choice
Stellar Windows Data Recovery logo
Editor's rating:
(4)
Simple, straightforward design
Overall great ease of use
Recovery of over 200 file types
Effective deep scans for internal drives
Complete solution
Disk Drill for Windows logo
Editor's rating:
(4)
Simple, straightforward user interface
Multiple customizable scanning options
Additional Recovery Vault protection
Free recovery of 500MB data
Beginners
Recuva logo
Editor's rating:
(4)
Simplified scanning with built-in wizard
Multi-language interface
Displays file condition
Option to overwrite/destroy data
User Feedback

 Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Best Reviews

Best Reviews may receive compensation for its content through paid collaborations and/or affiliate links. Learn more about how we sustain our work and review products.

©2012-2024 Best Reviews, a clovio brand – All rights reserved
Privacy policy · Cookie policy · Terms of use · Partnerships · Contact us