Disclaimer: We sustain our work & review products through paid collaborations.
Medical Alert Systems vs Mobile Phones for Seniors

Medical Alert Systems vs Mobile Phones for Seniors


People often sound out concerns about the usefulness of medical alert systems by claiming that the same results can be earned with a simple phone call. This is a flawed argument – there are several cases when a person is unable to speak for themselves – but in all fairness noteworthy alternatives do exist. For example, dedicated smartphone apps are popular among tech-savvy elderly people and those with serious medical conditions. In this case we mean standalone medical alert applications, not the ones provided by companies alongside their standard service.

Medical alert systems vs mobile phones for seniors

The pros of medical alert smartphone apps

As mentioned above, relying solely on a phone isn’t enough stay protected from unexpected emergencies. During a stroke or sudden seizure, victims quickly lose control over their body, rendering them unable to pull out their phones and call for an ambulance. As for elderly, they live in constant fear of falling and lying unconscious on the floor, and in this case calling for help is also out of question.

Medical alert smartphone apps are partial answers for such problems. They provide a means for users to set up custom contact lists, keep their medical history on file and, most importantly, dial 911 with a single touch of the screen. In some cases the software even sends a text message to specified end-users. It’s also not rare for apps to introduce other unique features, too. The Man Down App, for example, has fall detection: upon activating the mode the phone triggers the alarm when the user doesn’t change position for a couple of minutes. Standalone medical alert apps often come for free or charge only a one-time fee, which is only a fraction of the monthly commitment billed by a monitoring medical alert company.

Medication reminder watches vs apps
Free equipment on Medical Guardian's MGMini for limited time
Medical Guardian logo
Get the MGMini device at zero cost, free activation, free shipping, and a free lockbox by visiting Medical Guardian's website through our affiliate link. This offer is only available until April 23th.
Get MGMini for Free

Reliable help with medical alert systems

The problem with using your phone as a medical alert system is that it’s merely a life belt and not a fully developed safety net. Relying on your phone to effectively call for help is best suited for the younger generation or patients with less severe medical conditions. Despite charging you on a month by month basis, medical alert companies provide something invaluable: access to a team of monitoring experts. When pressing the button on your smartphone, you will still need to do most of the explaining to the dispatcher.

Medical Guardian's most advanced wireless button

Best medical alert systems of 2025

Editors' choice

Medical Guardian

Editor's rating:
Fast and helpful monitoring service
Reliable fall detection
Mobile monitoring solutions
Versatile pricing, no hidden charges
Value

MobileHelp

Editor's rating:
Advanced mobile unit
No landline required
Voice extension and fall detection
GPS system
Spanish

LifeFone

Editor's rating:
At-home and on-the-go solutions
One free month and free shipping
No equipment or activation fees
Price lock guarantee and no contract
Mobile system

Medical Alert

Editor's rating:
GPS tracking
Non-emergency support
Fall detection
140 languages
Professional installation

Lifeline

Editor's rating:
In-home and mobile devices
Smartphone app
No long-term contracts
+40 years of experience
Equipment variety

Alert1

Editor's rating:
Variety of systems
No equipment fees
No cancellation fees
Numerous accessories
Couples

One Call Alert

Editor's rating:
Customer service
No landline required
Fall detection and GPS tracking system
Free repairs and replacements

Discussions

Share your thoughts, ask questions, and connect with other users. Your feedback helps our community make better decisions.

©2012-2025 Best Reviews, a clovio brand – All rights reserved